Spoliation of Evidence in Ohio Personal Injury Cases

Personal Injury Lawyer Youngstown, Ohio

Spoliation of evidence happens when a party destroys, alters or fails to preserve evidence that matters to a lawsuit, whether the case has been filed or is only likely. In an Ohio personal injury case, losing a key video, record or vehicle can cripple a claim, so courts treat the destruction of evidence in a personal injury case seriously and injured people should act quickly to protect it.

Evidence is what proves the other party acted carelessly and that the carelessness caused your injury. If you were hurt because of someone else’s negligence, our Youngstown personal injury lawyers can step in early, while the evidence still exists.

What Is Spoliation of Evidence?

In the most basic terms, spoliation of evidence occurs when a party does not preserve evidence connected to a case, or deliberately destroys it. Once litigation is pending or reasonably expected, every party involved has a legal duty to preserve relevant evidence. That duty to preserve can begin before anyone files a lawsuit, which is why a business that hears about an injury on its property should not simply erase the footage and move on.

Spoliation can be intentional, like shredding a maintenance log, or careless, like letting a surveillance system record over the day of the accident. Either way, the party who had the legal duty to preserve that evidence is the one who answers for losing it.

What Happens When Evidence Is Destroyed in Ohio?

The consequences of spoliation depend on what was lost, why it was lost and how much it matters to the case. Ohio law offers several responses.

Court Sanctions in the Injury Case

The Ohio Supreme Court has noted that Civ.R. 37 provides trial courts with broad discretion to impose sanctions when a party breaks the discovery rules. When the opposing party fails to preserve the evidence, a judge may respond by:

  • Not allowing testimony about the missing evidence
  • Striking a defendant’s answer from the record
  • Choosing to instruct the jury about the missing evidence. This is often called an adverse inference instruction, because it lets jurors draw an adverse inference that the lost evidence would have hurt the party who destroyed it
  • In serious cases, entering a default judgment or ordering the party to pay attorney’s fees

A Separate Lawsuit for Intentional Spoliation

Ohio also recognizes spoliation of evidence as its own claim. In Smith v. Howard Johnson Co. (1993), the Ohio Supreme Court set out five elements of intentional spoliation: pending or probable litigation involving the plaintiff, the defendant’s knowledge of that litigation, willful destruction of evidence designed to disrupt the plaintiff’s case, actual disruption of the case, and damages caused by the defendant’s actions.

In 2018 the court narrowed that claim, holding that allegations of intentional interference with or concealment of evidence are not actionable under the independent tort of intentional spoliation of evidence, so this separate lawsuit is reserved for evidence that was actually destroyed. A court can still sanction hiding or interfering with evidence in the injury case itself.

Criminal Charges

Spoliation of evidence in Ohio can also be a crime. Under Ohio’s tampering with evidence statute, a person who knows an official proceeding or investigation is under way or likely, and who alters, destroys, conceals or removes a record, document or thing to impair its value as evidence, commits a felony of the third degree.

What Evidence Should Be Preserved?

Evidence after an accident disappears faster than most people expect. Important evidence in a personal injury case often includes:

  • Surveillance video from stores, parking lots and nearby businesses
  • Repair records, maintenance logs and inspection reports
  • Personnel records and a driver’s qualifications
  • Text messages, emails and backup data
  • Physical evidence, such as a broken railing, a defective product or the vehicles themselves
  • Black box and electronic logging device data from cars and commercial trucks
  • Medical records connected to the injury

Slip and Fall Evidence

After slip-and-fall accidents, the most critical evidence is often the condition of the floor or stairs and the store’s own video. A property owner may clean up a spill or repair a hazard before anyone documents it, and many camera systems record over old footage on a set schedule. If you were hurt in a fall, our Ohio slip and fall accident lawyer page explains how these claims work.

Truck Crash Evidence

Commercial trucks carry data about speed, braking and hours of service, and trucking companies keep driver files and maintenance records. Some of those records are kept only for a limited time. That is why an attorney handling a truck case will usually send a spoliation letter within days, so the data is still there when the case needs it.

What Is a Spoliation Letter?

A spoliation letter, also called a preservation letter, is a written notice an attorney sends to the party at fault, their insurer or anyone else holding evidence. In a crash case, our Ohio truck accident lawyer team sends one early so driver logs and electronic data are not lost. It puts the party on notice that litigation is likely and that all evidence related to the incident must be preserved.

What Should a Spoliation Letter Include?

A strong letter identifies the incident by date and place and lists the types of evidence to keep, such as video, repair records, personnel records, text messages, emails and electronic data. It also asks the recipient to stop any routine deletion that could erase relevant evidence.

When Should You Send a Spoliation Letter?

As soon as possible. A letter sent within days of an accident has a far better chance of saving video and electronic data than one sent months later. Once a party has received a spoliation letter, it becomes much harder for that party to claim it did not know the evidence mattered, which strengthens any later request for sanctions.

What to Do If You Suspect Evidence Was Destroyed

If you believe evidence was destroyed in your personal injury case, you still have rights. Write down what you remember about the evidence, keep copies of every letter and email about it, and save your own photos and records. Then talk to an attorney. A lawyer can use subpoenas, depositions and court motions to find out what happened, and can ask the court to respond if the duty to preserve was ignored.

Frequently Asked Questions

Spoliation of evidence can be a crime in Ohio when someone destroys or conceals evidence on purpose, knowing an official proceeding or investigation is under way or likely. Ohio’s tampering with evidence statute makes that a felony of the third degree.

Preservation of evidence means keeping evidence in its original condition once a lawsuit is pending or likely. That includes stopping routine deletion of video, emails and data that relate to the incident.

Proving spoliation usually means showing the evidence existed, that the other party knew a claim was likely, and that the evidence was lost or destroyed afterward. Spoliation letters, emails and deposition testimony often provide that proof.

Most civil cases, including personal injury cases, use the preponderance of the evidence standard, which means showing your version of events is more likely true than not. Missing evidence can make that harder, which is why preserving it matters.

Spoliation is a serious issue for both sides. The party who destroyed evidence may face court sanctions, a separate lawsuit or criminal charges, while the injured person may lose proof they needed.

Reviewed by Ilan Wexler, attorney at Anzellotti, Sperling, Pazol & Small. This article is general information about Ohio law, not legal advice for any specific case, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Talk to an Attorney About Evidence in Your Injury Case

If you are worried that evidence in your case is disappearing, Anzellotti, Sperling, Pazol & Small can help you protect it. Our firm has represented injured people in the Mahoning Valley since 1971. Call ASP&S ASAP at 330-778-ASAP (2727) or 330-792-6033, or schedule a free consultation.

Anzellotti, Sperling, Pazol & Small
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.